ZY CleanroomTIANJIN · SINCE 2002 Get a budget range

Buyer guide

Laminar flow hood vs clean bench vs biosafety cabinet

A laminar flow hood and a clean bench are the same kind of device: they blow HEPA-filtered air over the work to protect the product, not the operator. A biosafety cabinet (BSC) is built to protect the operator and the room: Class I and II draw air in at the front, and Class II also protects the product.

By ZY Cleanroom · Updated · Sources at the end of the page

How the devices differ

In common use, laminar flow hood and clean bench name one device. The CDC and NIH biosafety manual (BMBL, 6th edition) calls them clean benches or clean air devices, and says they are not BSCs.

DeviceAir pathProtects
Horizontal clean benchHEPA air from the back, across the work, toward the userProduct only
Vertical clean benchHEPA air downward; discharged into the room under the sashProduct only
Class I BSCRoom air in at the front, HEPA filter on exhaust; inflow at least 75 lfm (0.38 m/s)Operator and room, not product
Class II, Type A1Inflow at least 75 lfm (0.38 m/s); HEPA downflowOperator, room and product
Class II, Type A2Inflow at least 100 lfm (0.51 m/s); HEPA downflowOperator, room and product
Class III BSCGas-tight cabinet with attached glovesMaximum protection for worker and environment
Laminar flow hood vs clean bench vs biosafety cabinet

What may go inside

BMBL says clean benches should never be used with cell culture materials, drug formulations, potentially infectious materials or other potentially hazardous materials. The worker is downstream of the work and is exposed.

BMBL lists dust-free assembly of sterile equipment or electronic devices as a use for a horizontal bench. It lists hospital pharmacy intravenous preparation and nucleic acid preparation for PCR as uses for a vertical bench. If the material is hazardous or infectious, choose a BSC.

Air speed for product protection

FDA's 2004 aseptic guidance gives 0.45 m/s with ±20%. Annex 1 para 4.30 gives 0.36 to 0.54 m/s at the working position as a guidance value.

Worked example, assumed size: a filter face of 1.2 × 0.6 m is 0.72 m². At 0.36 m/s the face airflow is 0.72 × 0.36 × 3,600 = 933 m³/h. At 0.54 m/s it is 1,400 m³/h. This is a design check. Test velocity where your protocol says.

Certification and the room around it

BMBL says a BSC must be validated before use and after repair or relocation, and tested and certified at least annually. It asks for recertification after a HEPA or ULPA filter change. NSF/ANSI 49 covers Class II cabinets.

USP <797> asks that a primary engineering control meet ISO Class 5 or better in dynamic conditions, with unidirectional airflow maintained. A control used only for Category 1 preparations may stand in an unclassified segregated compounding area. In a classified ISO Class 7 room, USP <797> asks for at least 30 total HEPA-filtered air changes per hour.

Choosing in three questions

What is handled? If it is infectious, hazardous, a cell culture or a drug formulation, a clean bench is excluded by BMBL. Who needs protection? If the operator does, choose a BSC. What air quality does the work need? If only the product does, a clean bench is the listed use.

China's cleanroom construction code lists biosafety cabinet installation as its own item (clause 11.4) and an isolation coefficient test for biosafety cabinets (Appendix F.3). A Chinese project may need both on the test plan.

Put these in the data sheet

State the device class, the ISO class in operation, the material to be handled and its hazard, the inflow and downflow speeds, the filter grade, the certification standard, the service access and the alarms. Say who certifies it and when.

Who approves the room

Your regulator or biosafety officer judges the facility. The contractor builds to your data sheet and supplies test results. The owner keeps the responsibility. To have a room list reviewed, send it to ZY Cleanroom, a cleanroom design-and-build contractor with its own panel factory in Tianjin, China.

Questions

Common questions

Is a laminar flow hood the same as a biosafety cabinet?

No. A laminar flow hood or clean bench protects the product only and blows air toward the user. A BSC draws air in at the front to protect the operator.

Can I use a clean bench for cell culture?

BMBL says clean benches should never be used for cell culture materials, drug formulations or potentially infectious materials. Choose a BSC.

What inflow does a Class II cabinet need?

BMBL gives at least 75 lfm (0.38 m/s) for Type A1 and at least 100 lfm (0.51 m/s) for Type A2.

How often is a BSC certified?

BMBL says at least annually, and again after relocation, repair or a HEPA or ULPA filter change.

Related guides

Sources

Project enquiry

Send what you have

A room list, a floor plan or only the floor area is enough to start. After you submit, send drawings by email or WhatsApp.

We reply by email within one working day. We can sign an NDA before you send drawings.

WhatsApp +44 7962 561184 is our UK number for export enquiries. The factory is in Tianjin, China.

Email: [email protected]
WhatsApp: +44 7962 561184

Step 1 of 2

WhatsAppGet a budget range